High-Level Architectural Guide

This guide covers higher-level considerations that every developer should be aware of when coding in C++. They are complementary to the other development guides; if you find a conflict between another guide and this one, that’s a bug–please report it.

Software Architecture…The Important Stuff

  1. Software architecture always traces back to the business model for the company, and considers the implications of that for software development.

  2. The success of a given software architecture is measured by how well said software aligns with the business model.

  3. Characteristics of a successful software architecture:

  4. Adoption of engineering practices that provide repeatable benefits, including:

    • `Architectural Constraints`_: rules for the system, what is and is not allowed.

    • Principles and models: guidelines for how developers should go about implementing features. Basically, the combination of OOP Software Design Principles And Patterns. and the guide for your programming language (e.g., C++ Development Guide for C++).

    • Structure: the building blocks of the system and how they should fit together.

    • OOP Design Patterns and understandability: same problem, same solution; document, document, document (not for the developer that wrote it!).

    • Detailed designs: How does the SW implement architectural elements in ways that align with the overall goals of the system ?

    • Testing environments: how can we test what we produce and ensure everything we produce works, continues to work, and aligns with the overall goals of the system.

    • Release environments: how can we make releases of our system in a way that works, continues to work, and aligns with the overall goals of the system.

Important

Architecture, software design and implementation, testing and release need to work and play well together, otherwise you don’t have an architecture–just a collection of stuff that doesn’t “hang together” in any meaningful way.

Craig’s Laws of Software Architecture

  1. Everything Is A Trade-Off

    If you think you’ve found something that does not involve a trade-off, you just haven’t identified the trade-off yet

  2. Why Is More Important Than How

    Always capture why an architectural decision was made: in a design document, class comment header, etc. If you only consider how things are done now, and you invent a new “better” way to do it, you may miss very important reasons why it was originally done differently.

  3. There Is Always A Bigger Picture

    Remember that there are “important things to consider” that may not be immediately clear when looking at design/implementation details at any level of abstraction

    The biggest picture (TM) involves business goals (of our company and partners); moving down to architecture, designs, implementations testing, release and maintenance.

  4. Embrace change

    Continuous improvement is not just a Japanese auto manufacturer thing; being static or unchanging is typically not a natural or desirable state. The needs of the business will change over time, and the architecture (whatever that is) will need to adapt to change with it.